01:4670% Chinese Want to Get Slimmer?Read

Jun

18

2005

Via Xinhuanet.

Sounds so promising huh? This is the result of a survey conducted from May 9 to 13 by China Youth Daily. People might cheer up on the conclusion that "obesity has taken the place of famine as one of the Chinese' top concerns."

But that's the real case? I'm so skeptical about the survey so let's just read it through.

The survey collected 3,858 responses in China's 33 provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities, including Hong Kong and Macao, and had 54.8 percent women participants and 72.4 percent youth aged from 20 to 30.

The sampling method was not mentioned in the news story. The reporter might think nothing of it or regard it as of no interest to readers. Therefore I can't get more informaiton on it but I'm 99.9% sure that it was not a probability sampling. I even don't expect it will be. Mail-based survey targeting CYD's readers is the most likely one. Or it might be telephone or the Internet survey. Anyway, any of the three ways will produce seriously biased sample--how much did the survey cover people living out of cities? I mean over 900 million farmer population? I don't think a significant portition of them are subscribers of CYD. Moreover, the sample was seriously biased toward younger people, say, those between 20-30. That is evident since the targeted readership of CYD is undoubtedly younger population.

It is fun to see that the reporter tried to emphasize the "generalizability" of the survey by stating "33 provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities, including Hong Kong and Macao" were covered. So was the sample in each province consistent with its population quote? I highly doubt about that.

The news story looks more like a joke than a survey. I'm sure not too many people will take it seriously but what is noteworthy is the over-optimism Chinese media hold about the well-being of Chinese people.

1Darren on June 29, 2005 11:13 PM |

I don't think so. Many rural areas in China are still so poor that food is scarce. Kids begging on the streets and all.

2Alcor on July 18, 2005 7:39 PM |

I can always find interesting things and voices of a little unconventionality here. From this GRE-argument-style article, I get enough testimonies that you must have done it well.

Can we make friends?

POST A COMMENT

Please be considerate of others. Keep comments relevant. Content deemed inappropriate or offensive may be edited and/or deleted. Email addresses are never displayed.

    *

    *

Remember me    

smile big grin blush cool tongue innocent laugh roll eyes music wink wub whistling heart
confused no expression sad sad 1 shocked crazy cry angry sick sleeping unsured censored